Overall Score
Eden Economics is a visually stunning, faith-forward financial education site with gorgeous design and compelling messaging, but it stumbles on accessibility, mobile UX, and conversion optimization—leaving money on the table despite having all the right pieces.
The Roast
This website is like a perfectly decorated church potluck where half the dishes are cold by the time you eat them. The design is absolutely *chef's kiss*—those garden visuals, the gold accents, the serif typography all scream 'we hired someone who knows what they're doing.' But then you try to use it on mobile and suddenly you're squinting at form fields like you forgot your reading glasses at home. The form itself is a masterclass in asking for everything except your blood type, and three images are running around without alt text like they're playing hide-and-seek with screen readers. It's gorgeous, it's faithful, but it's also a little bit lazy where it counts.
🎯 Start Here
Mobile
Accessibility
Conversion
SEO
Trust Signals
Performance
Design & UX
Copy & Messaging
Mobile
Mobile responsiveness is present but clunky—the hamburger menu works, but the hero text is cramped, form fields are too small, and the overall experience feels like a desktop site squeezed into a phone rather than a mobile-first design.
Issues Found
- Hero text ('IN THE GARDEN OF YOUR FINANCIAL LIFE, THERE ARE TWO TREES. Choose Wisely.') wraps awkwardly and becomes hard to read on 375px screens
- Form fields lack adequate padding and are difficult to tap; no visible focus states for keyboard navigation
- Navigation menu collapses to hamburger but doesn't show visual feedback when opened (no animation or clear state change visible in screenshots)
Recommendations
-
Redesign mobile hero for readability high
Use smaller font sizes (clamp() function) and shorter line lengths; consider stacking text vertically or using a mobile-specific headline (e.g., 'Choose Wisely' alone) to improve readability.
-
Improve form field touch targets high
Increase input height to 48px minimum, add 12px+ padding, and ensure 16px+ font size to prevent zoom-on-focus on iOS.
-
Add visual feedback to mobile menu medium
Animate the hamburger icon (e.g., rotate or transform to X) and add a visible overlay or slide-in animation when the menu opens.
Accessibility
The site has good bones (22 ARIA attributes, skip link present, proper landmarks, all form inputs labeled), but the missing alt text, potential color contrast issues, and mobile form usability create barriers for users with disabilities.
Issues Found
- Three images missing alt text (confirmed in crawl data)—screen reader users will encounter empty or generic alt text
- Gold/orange text on light backgrounds (e.g., 'Live the Life You Teach' in gold on ivory) may fail WCAG AA contrast ratio (4.5:1 for normal text)
- Form inputs on mobile are too small (44px minimum not met)—keyboard and touch users will struggle to interact
Recommendations
-
Add descriptive alt text to all images high
Write alt text that conveys the image's purpose and content; for decorative images, use empty alt='' to hide from screen readers.
-
Test and fix color contrast high
Use a contrast checker (e.g., WebAIM) to verify that gold/orange text meets WCAG AA (4.5:1) or AAA (7:1) standards; darken text or lighten background if needed.
-
Increase form field sizes and spacing high
Ensure all form inputs are at least 44px tall with adequate padding; add focus indicators (outline or border change) for keyboard navigation.
Conversion
The conversion funnel is present (hero CTA → form submission) but lacks supporting elements like social proof, testimonials, or urgency signals. The form itself is comprehensive but may be too long, and there's no clear post-submission experience or follow-up messaging.
Issues Found
- Form has 9 fields (name, church name, email, phone, city/state, workshop interest, attendees, timeframe, notes)—this is long and may cause abandonment; no progress indicator or field validation feedback visible
- No testimonials or case studies visible in the captured screenshots—churches can't see proof that this works for other congregations
- No urgency or scarcity messaging (e.g., 'Limited workshop slots available' or 'Book by [date]')—no reason to act now
Recommendations
-
Shorten the form or add progress indicator high
Either reduce to 5-6 essential fields (name, church name, email, workshop interest, timeframe) or add a progress bar showing 'Step 1 of 2' to reduce perceived friction.
-
Add testimonials or case study section high
Include 2-3 short testimonials from churches that have completed the workshop, with quotes about outcomes (e.g., 'Our congregation reduced debt by 30%' or 'Members now have monthly financial conversations').
-
Add urgency or social proof messaging medium
Include a line like 'Join 50+ churches already teaching financial stewardship' or 'Limited workshop dates available—request your slot today' to encourage immediate action.
SEO
The site has solid foundational SEO (good meta description, proper heading hierarchy, 1487 words of content), but it's missing schema markup, has thin content in places, and lacks internal linking strategy to guide search engines through the site structure.
Issues Found
- No schema markup detected (no Organization, LocalBusiness, or FAQPage schema)—search engines can't easily extract key facts like phone number, address, or service details
- Heading hierarchy is present but not optimized—8 h2s and 12 h3s suggest some sections may be over-segmented or lack clear parent-child relationships
- Limited internal linking strategy—navigation is present but body content doesn't link between related sections (e.g., 'The Workshops' section doesn't link to 'The Approach')
Recommendations
-
Add structured data markup high
Implement Organization schema (name, logo, contact, address) and LocalBusiness schema to help Google understand who you are and where you operate.
-
Audit and flatten heading hierarchy medium
Ensure each h2 has 1-2 h3s max; if you have orphaned h3s or multiple h2s at the same level, restructure to create a clear outline.
-
Add contextual internal links medium
In body copy, link 'The Workshops' to the workshops section, 'The Approach' to the approach section, etc., to improve crawlability and user navigation.
Trust Signals
The site establishes credibility through Dolores Sherman's credentials (AFC®), faith-based messaging, and professional design, but it lacks third-party validation like testimonials, case studies, certifications, or social proof that would reassure churches this is worth their time and money.
Issues Found
- No visible testimonials or case studies in the captured screenshots—churches can't see proof of success from other congregations
- Credentials are mentioned (AFC®) but not explained—most church leaders won't know what AFC means or why it matters
- No social proof metrics (e.g., 'Trusted by 50+ churches' or 'Over 5,000 members trained')—no quantifiable evidence of impact
Recommendations
-
Add testimonials with specific outcomes high
Include 2-3 quotes from church leaders or members with measurable results (e.g., 'Our congregation reduced average household debt by 25%' or 'Members report more confident financial conversations').
-
Explain Dolores Sherman's credentials medium
Add a brief bio or 'About the Facilitator' section that explains what AFC® means (Accredited Financial Counselor) and why it matters for churches.
-
Add social proof metrics medium
Include a stat like 'Trusted by 50+ churches across the US' or 'Over 10,000 members trained in biblical financial stewardship' to build confidence.
Performance
Performance was not measured via PageSpeed Insights, so this assessment is based on HTML structure only. The site loads 10 images (3 missing alt text), uses semantic HTML, and has no obvious render-blocking scripts in the head—but lazy-loading attributes are not visible in the provided code, and image formats/sizes are not optimized.
Issues Found
- Three images lack alt text (per crawl data), which blocks both accessibility and image SEO
- No lazy-loading attributes visible on images—all 10 images may load on page load, increasing initial payload
- Large hero image (garden scene with flowers) is likely high-resolution; no srcset or picture element detected for responsive image delivery
Recommendations
-
Add alt text to all images high
Audit all 10 images and add descriptive alt text to the 3 missing ones; use alt text that describes the image content and context (e.g., 'Family in church reviewing financial documents' for the family photo).
-
Implement lazy-loading for below-the-fold images medium
Add loading='lazy' attribute to images that appear below the fold (e.g., product images, testimonial photos) to defer their loading until needed.
-
Optimize hero image with responsive formats medium
Use WebP format with JPEG fallback and srcset to serve appropriately-sized images to different devices (e.g., 1920px for desktop, 768px for tablet, 375px for mobile).
Design & UX
The design is genuinely beautiful—sophisticated color palette, excellent typography hierarchy, and thematic imagery that reinforces the faith-based message. However, the desktop-first approach leaves mobile users squinting, and some spacing/layout decisions feel more decorative than functional.
Issues Found
- Mobile navigation collapses to hamburger menu but the hero image and text don't scale gracefully—'Choose Wisely' text becomes cramped and hard to read on small screens
- Form fields on mobile (screenshot 5) are cramped with minimal padding, making them difficult to tap accurately
- Inconsistent spacing between sections; some have generous breathing room while others feel dense and cluttered
Recommendations
-
Optimize hero text for mobile readability high
Reduce font sizes on mobile using clamp() or media queries so 'IN THE GARDEN OF YOUR FINANCIAL LIFE' doesn't wrap awkwardly or overflow on screens under 480px.
-
Increase form field touch targets high
Add minimum 44px height to all input fields and increase padding to meet WCAG touch target guidelines (48x48px recommended).
-
Improve section spacing consistency medium
Audit margin/padding between major sections and establish a consistent vertical rhythm (e.g., 40px, 60px, 80px) to reduce visual chaos.
Copy & Messaging
The messaging is emotionally resonant and theologically grounded—'Choose Wisely,' 'Live the Life You Teach,' and 'When their house suffers, God's house suffers' are all compelling hooks. The value proposition is crystal clear: faith-based financial education for congregations. However, some CTAs are buried or lack urgency.
Issues Found
- Primary CTA ('Request Information') is prominent in the header but secondary CTAs throughout the page lack visual hierarchy—they blend into body text
- The form's submit button says 'YES! LET'S CULTIVATE CHANGE' which is thematic but doesn't clearly communicate what happens next (e.g., 'Submit Request' or 'Schedule a Call')
- No clear pricing, timeline, or outcome messaging—churches don't know what they're signing up for beyond 'workshops'
Recommendations
-
Clarify CTA language and outcomes high
Change form submit button to 'Schedule Your Free Consultation' or similar, and add a line above the form explaining what happens after submission (e.g., 'Dolores will contact you within 2 business days').
-
Add pricing/timeline transparency medium
Include a brief FAQ or 'What to Expect' section that outlines workshop duration, cost, and typical outcomes so churches can make informed decisions.
-
Strengthen secondary CTAs medium
Make links to 'The Workshops,' 'The Approach,' and 'The Testimonials' visually distinct (e.g., underline, color change, or button styling) so they feel clickable.
Think you can beat 74/100?
Get your site brutally analyzed by the same AI. 8 scores, a punch list of fixes, 60 seconds.